LSAT ScorePath editorial resources · Original teaching exercises
LSAT Strengthen vs. Weaken: Test the Causal Link
The deciding distinction
For a causal argument, a strengthen answer can reduce a rival explanation; a weaken answer can introduce one. Evaluate what the answer does to the link between evidence and conclusion. An answer need not prove or disprove the conclusion.
Work through a before-and-after comparison, then transfer the method to a comparison between groups. These are simplified teaching illustrations, not official LSAT questions or a calibrated test of readiness.
1. Weaken: what else changed?
A library introduced automatic renewal reminders in September. The proportion of borrowed books returned late was lower in September than in August. The director concludes that the reminders caused the decrease. Which finding, if true, most weakens the director’s argument?
Carry the method, not the topic
Write three short lines before reading the next set of choices: the proposed cause, the measured outcome, and another difference that could explain that outcome. Then check the question’s direction. The same alternative explanation may help on a weaken question and hurt on a strengthen question.
2. Strengthen: isolate the difference
A delivery company tested a new routing program on half of its drivers for one month. Drivers using the program made a smaller proportion of late deliveries than drivers who did not use it. A manager concludes that the program reduced late deliveries. Which finding, if true, most strengthens the manager’s argument?
Review the two closest choices
Comparison
Deciding difference
Next-action rule
Library: B versus D
B gives another cause of the decrease. D only shows that the decrease was not complete.
Distinguish “less often” from “never.”
Routing: C versus A
C addresses differences between the groups. A describes an appealing feature without isolating its effect.
Prefer evidence about the causal inference over general praise for the proposed cause.
Try it on fresh official practice
Choose a small set of strengthen and weaken questions from your authorized practice resource. Keep the answer key closed.
State the conclusion and evidence in your own words. For causal arguments, name one rival explanation.
For each finalist, finish this sentence: “If true, this makes the conclusion more or less supported because…” An irrelevant answer may do neither.
Check the explanation and record the exact difference you missed. Revisit the method on unfamiliar material; two illustrations do not establish mastery.
Not every strengthen or weaken argument is causal. For other arguments, identify the specific gap or relationship rather than forcing a causal explanation.
These original teaching exercises were prepared by LSAT ScorePath with AI assistance and editorial checks. Sameer Rai has not personally written or reviewed them. They are not official LSAT questions, validated diagnostics, or evidence of student results. Difficulty labels are not calibrated to official LSAT performance. Our editorial approach.