LSAT ScorePath →

LSAT ScorePath editorial resources · Original teaching exercises

Understand the Explanation, Still Miss the Next Question?

Understanding is a starting point

An explanation can feel clear because someone else has supplied the missing step. Check your understanding by making the same distinction independently on unfamiliar material.

This clinic tests a common reasoning move: an improvement measured over time is not automatically evidence that a particular intervention caused it.

1. Find the missing comparison

A school began a voluntary evening workshop. Students who attended raised their average practice score by six points during the semester. The director concludes that the workshop caused this improvement. Which finding most weakens the argument?

Choose the best answer

Pause before the second exercise

Close the explanation mentally and state the repair in your own words. “Find a control group” is incomplete: the group must be relevantly comparable, and its result changes the strength of the claim without automatically proving a cause.

2. Transfer: same reasoning, different surface

A clinic introduced reminder texts for appointments. Missed appointments fell from 18% to 11% the following month. Its manager attributes the decline to the texts. Which question would be most useful in evaluating that attribution?

Choose the best answer

A useful review entry

Temptation: I treated a before-and-after improvement as proof of the program’s effect.

Deciding evidence: A similar improvement without the program shows that the change might have happened anyway.

Next action: On fresh causal questions, identify the comparison and ask whether the groups differ in another relevant way.

Recheck: Try an unfamiliar official question later, before consulting this entry. Record whether you generated the distinction independently.

What these two answers can tell you

If you solved the second question with the same reasoning, you demonstrated transfer across these two illustrations. That is a useful observation, not evidence of a score gain or mastery. If you missed it, identify the mismatch between the question’s causal task and the issue your chosen answer addressed.

Preserve an independent second attempt · Record your next-action rule

Sources and editorial notes

These original teaching exercises were prepared by LSAT ScorePath with AI assistance and editorial checks. Sameer Rai has not personally written or reviewed them. They are not official LSAT questions, validated diagnostics, or evidence of student results. Difficulty labels are not calibrated to official LSAT performance. Our editorial approach.

Use LSAC’s question-type guidance and authorized official practice to test your skills more broadly.