LSAT ScorePath →

LSAT ScorePath editorial resources · Original teaching exercises

LSAT Reading Comprehension: Choosing Between Two Answers

When two answers seem right

Find the smallest meaningful difference between them, then identify what the passage actually commits to. A true detail can still misrepresent the author’s main point or the relationship between two views.

These finalists use plausible, qualified wording. The deciding issue is how they connect the passage’s ideas.

Read once, then name the author’s position

Some cities have replaced fixed-rate curbside parking with prices that vary by demand. Supporters argue that higher prices on crowded blocks encourage turnover and reduce the time drivers spend searching for spaces. Critics respond that a pricing system can impose a disproportionate burden on lower-income workers whose schedules give them little flexibility.

A recent pilot reported shorter searches for parking after variable prices were introduced. However, the pilot also coincided with a new shuttle service connecting an inexpensive remote lot to the city center. Because the study did not isolate the effects of these changes, it cannot establish how much of the improvement came from pricing.

The pilot therefore offers a reason to investigate variable pricing further, rather than a sufficient basis for adopting it citywide. A useful next study would distinguish the effects of pricing from those of improved transport and examine who bears the resulting costs.

1. Main point: both finalists mention evidence

Which statement best captures the author’s position?

Choose the best answer

Why reasonable answers lose

The strongest wrong answers often reuse the right subject and a defensible concern, then alter the recommendation, population, or logical relationship. Underline the changed phrase before rereading the whole passage. A wording difference matters only if it changes what is supported.

2. Transfer: distinguish two related views

Passage A: A university should make recorded lectures available because students can revisit difficult explanations. Recordings are a useful supplement to attendance, especially when a lecture introduces unfamiliar terminology.

Passage B: Recordings can help students revisit explanations. But in a course studied last year, students who relied on recordings while rarely attending class did worse on assessments. This result does not establish that recordings caused the lower performance; it does suggest studying how students use them.

Which best describes the relationship?

Choose the best answer

Your next official passage

For each uncertain question, preserve both finalists. Record the exact difference, the supporting sentence or relationship, and why the rejected choice goes beyond it. A correct answer reached by guessing still deserves review. If your passage map did not help find that evidence, shorten or revise it.

Review passage mapping and answer traps · Test transfer after an explanation

Sources and editorial notes

These original teaching exercises were prepared by LSAT ScorePath with AI assistance and editorial checks. Sameer Rai has not personally written or reviewed them. They are not official LSAT questions, validated diagnostics, or evidence of student results. Difficulty labels are not calibrated to official LSAT performance. Our editorial approach.

Use LSAC’s question-type guidance and authorized official practice to test your skills more broadly.